Blind Item...I Guess...You Guess...

This Blind Item comes from Gatecrasher:

Which famous New York athlete who used to date a pint-size actress is still shaking his head about how she would never remove her shoes during sex?

The first athlete I thought of was Derek Jeter. He dated Jessica Alba, but I wouldn't call her pint-sized. Then I thought of Sean Avery who dated Elisha Cuthbert. She's 5'2". My guess is Sean and Elisha? Take your shoes off ho! Wait, unless he's into stiletto anal sex....